Manchester United committed up to £155m to three central midfielders this summer. By the end of October, the trio had no Premier League goals between them, and they had gone nine matches without a win in all competitions, a run extended by a 2-0 defeat at Chelsea on 31 October. With a trip to Anfield due after the international break, anyone weighing up the Liverpool vs Man U odds will want to know whether the new midfield is any closer to working.
The spending was not optional. Casemiro had left, and Manuel Ugarte suffered a serious knee injury at the World Cup, so the middle of the pitch needed rebuilding before a ball was kicked. Three months on, each signing tells a different story.
Youri Tielemans: 6.5/10
Tielemans was the cheapest of the three and has been the most useful. United triggered his £35m release clause at Aston Villa on 14 July and handed him a five-year contract running to June 2031. He arrived with recent big-game pedigree, having scored the opening goal in Villa’s Europa League final win over Freiburg last season.
He started all eight of United’s league games up to late October, playing 588 minutes. His passing has stood out. After five rounds, fewer than 5% of Premier League players had made more line-breaking passes than his 94, and he ranked in the top 10% for completed passes (314) and defensive recoveries (25).
The output is the problem. One assist and no goals from the most-used midfielder in a team that has won once in the league is not enough, and the rating reflects that. He is the one signing they can rely on every week, which says as much about the other two as it does about him.
Andrey Santos: 5.5/10
Santos was United’s first signing of the window, joining from Chelsea on 13 July for £48m plus £2m in add-ons, also on a deal to 2031. The 22-year-old came with experience beyond his age, having had loan spells at Vasco da Gama, Nottingham Forest and Strasbourg before returning to Stamford Bridge for 2025-26.
He impressed in pre-season and started the opening Premier League game, but has rarely been a first choice since. By late October he had made three league starts and played 262 minutes, with no goals or assists. Most of his appearances have come from the bench or in the Carabao Cup.
The fee demands more than a rotation role. Equally, it is hard to judge a midfielder who has not had a proper run in the side, so the jury is still out rather than in.
Carlos Baleba: 5/10
Baleba was the headline deal. United completed his move from Brighton on 25 August for £65m, with a further £5m in add-ons, a year after Brighton had reportedly wanted more than £100m for him.
He arrived carrying an ankle injury and having missed Brighton’s entire pre-season, and it has shown. Up to late October, the 22-year-old had started two Premier League games and played 175 minutes. He also started the Champions League defeat at Atletico Madrid.
This rating is about availability more than ability. Baleba has the physical profile United’s midfield has lacked, but £70m buys a player who is expected to be fit and in the team, and that has not happened yet.
What comes next
The schedule gives the new midfield little time to settle. United face Roma in the Champions League on 3 November and host Aston Villa on 8 November, when Tielemans meets his former club. The trip to Liverpool follows straight after the international break.
Reports suggest the club wants an improvement before that break. Whether it comes will depend heavily on Baleba getting fit, Santos getting minutes and Tielemans adding goals to his passing. For anyone looking to bet online on United’s next few fixtures, the team sheet will reveal how much faith the club has in his summer arrivals.
For now, United have one dependable signing, one barely used and one barely fit, and not a single league goal from any of them.